Plane Crash List

McDonnell Douglas MD-11 N809DE

1 April 2002 · Charlotte, North Carolina, United States · Serious injuries

Summary

On 1 April 2002 at about 00:45 local time, a McDonnell Douglas MD-11 registered N809DE was involved in an accident near Charlotte, North Carolina, United States. 245 people were on board and 5 were seriously injured, 11 had minor injuries. The aircraft was slightly damaged. The NTSB has published a probable cause for this accident; it is quoted in full below.

The record

Date
at 00:45
Classification
Accident
Location
Charlotte, North Carolina, United States
Nearest airport
Charlotte Douglas Internationa (KCLT)
Coordinates
35.2142, -80.9431
Aircraft
McDonnell Douglas MD-11
Registration
N809DE
Category
Airplane
Engines
3
Operator
Not recorded
Operating rule
Part 121: Air Carrier
Phase of flight
Not recorded
Route
Atlanta → London
Aircraft damage
Minor
Weather
IMC
Light
Night
NTSB number
MIA02FA075

People

5 people were seriously injured.

On board Died Serious Minor Uninjured
245 0 5 11 229

Probable cause

The failure of the aircraft operator to comply with, in a timely manner, on the No. 2 engine, Boeing Alert Service Bulletin MD11-71A086, resulting in the integrated drive generator feeder cable chaffing through a fire warning loop and failure of the fire warning system due to electrical damage. This resulted in a continuous indication in the cockpit of a No. 2 engine fire, an emergency descent and landing, and injuries to passengers during the subsequent emergency evacuation of the airplane.

Quoted verbatim from the NTSB record. This site does not paraphrase or interpret it.

Read the full NTSB narrative

The captain stated he was the pilot flying and the takeoff and climb to the cruise altitude of 33,000 feet was conducted within normal parameters. After level off the relief pilot left the cockpit to begin his rest period. Within a few minutes he observed that the number 2 engine master warning light was illuminated, as well as a level 3 alert on the Engine and Alert Display and a red light on the number 2 fire handle and fuel shutoff lever. The fire bell did not activate. He and the first officer performed the memory and initial action items on the hard card checklists for an engine fire and shutdown the No. 2 engine. In addition, the captain discharged an engine fire bottle. The engine fire light continued to illuminate. The captain then fired a second engine fire bottle. The engine fire light continued to be illuminated. The captain requested that the relief pilot return to the cockpit. He then contacted Air Traffic Control (ATC) and told them that their No. 2 engine was on fire and that they intended to land at the nearest suitable field. ATC responded that Charlotte was 35 miles away with a 10,000 foot runway. He asked for radar vectors and an immediate descent into Charlotte. They were given a lower altitude. The first officer initiated fuel dumping. The relief pilot returned to the cockpit and he asked the relief pilot and the first officer to run the checklists. As they descended the aircraft encountered heavy rain, light hail, and moderate turbulence. In addition, they observed a bright flash to the left of the nose, which might have been a lightning strike. As they completed the descent and approach checklists he told the crew to expect an emergency evacuation upon landing and directed the first officer to so inform the flight attendants. The aircraft was configured for an engine out approach and they reviewed the loss of a second engine procedure. The remainder of the approach, touchdown and landing roll occurred within normal parameters. He brought the airplane to a stop on the runway. The engine fire indication remained illuminated. The relief pilot stated they did not terminate fuel dumping prior to landing. They completed the items on the evacuation checklist. He then ordered an evacuation of the airplane. According to Delta Air Lines representatives, examination of the No. 2 engine by company maintenance personnel found one fire loop chafed through an adjacent cable, an integrated drive generator (IDG) feeder cable, inside the No. 2 engine cowling This allowed a direct 115 volt AC connection between the IDG and the fire detection control unit. The result was an electrical short and complete failure of the detection control unit that was indicated in the cockpit as a fire warning. There was no evidence of fire in the No. 2 engine. Boeing Service Bullettin MD11-71-086 was issued on May 21, 1996. The subject of the service bulletin was "Power Plant - Electrical Harness - Replace/Modify Integrated Drive Generator (IDG) Wire Harness Support Brackets". On May 21, 2001, Boeing elevated the service bulletin to the "Alert" level. Boeing recommended that aircraft operators accomplish the service bulletin within 1 year. According to Delta Air Lines personnel, in November 2001, Delta Air Lines Aircraft Engineering issued a Engineering Order to comply with Alert Service Bulletin MD11-71A086. The Engineering Order stated that all engines should be inspected and modified by November 2002. All three engines on the accident aircraft were inspected and modified in accordance with the Engineering Order on March 3, 2002. On March 28, 2002, the No. 2 engine was changed and the engine installed had not been modified by the Engineering Order.The Delta Airlines descent, approach, and before landing checklists dated June 30, 2000, and which were in use at the time of the accident, required the pilots to check the Engine and Alert Display. When fuel dumping is activated, a message is displayed on the Engine and Alert Display.

Quoted verbatim from the NTSB record.

Other McDonnell Douglas MD-11 accidents

Date Aircraft Location Operator Outcome Died
3 Jun 2002 McDonnell Douglas MD-11
N588FE
Subic Bay, Philippines
no coordinates
Federal Express Corp No injuries -
14 Jan 2003 McDonnell Douglas MD-11-C
I-DUPA
Jamaica, New York, United States - No injuries -
20 Nov 2001 McDonnell Douglas MD-11
B-16101
Taipei, Taiwan
no coordinates
EVA AIr Unknown -
15 Jan 2003 McDonnell Douglas MD-11
N583FE
Stansted, United Kingdom
no coordinates
Federal Express Corp No injuries -
29 Sep 2000 McDonnell Douglas MD-11 Subic Bay, Philippines
no coordinates
Federal Express Corp No injuries -
26 Jan 2004 McDonnell Douglas MD-11
PP-VTF
Mexico City, Mexico
no coordinates
Varig Airlines No injuries -

All 42 records for this type

Other accidents in this area

Date Aircraft Location Operator Outcome Died
20 Sep 2002 Mooney M20R
N574DJ
Burnsville, North Carolina, United States Carol G. Peddy Fatal 2
14 Mar 2002 Piper PA32R-300
N4451X
Broadway, North Carolina, United States RAM Air Freight Inc Fatal 1
14 Jul 2002 Piper PA-31-325
N27626
Weaverville, North Carolina, United States Avery Eugene Cleland No injuries -
16 Jun 2002 Cessna 152
N68437
Greenville, North Carolina, United States - Minor injuries -
13 Jan 2002 Cessna 172M
N9334H
Sanford, North Carolina, United States - No injuries -
15 Nov 2002 Piper PA-28-140
N8162N
Climax, North Carolina, United States - Fatal 1

All 170,864 records in United States